The Noctua NH-D15 G2 LBC Cooler Review: Notoriously Big, Incredibly Good
by E. Fylladitakis on August 12, 2024 12:00 PM EST- Posted in
- Cases/Cooling/PSUs
- Noctua
- Cooler
- Air Cooling
When you buy a retail computer CPU, it usually comes with a standard cooler. However, most enthusiasts find that the stock cooler just does not cut it in terms of performance. So, they often end up getting a more advanced cooler that better suits their needs. Choosing the right cooler isn't a one-size-fits-all deal – it is a bit of a journey. You have to consider what you need, what you want, your budget, and how much space you have in your setup. All these factors come into play when picking out the perfect cooler.
When it comes to high-performance coolers, Noctua is a name that frequently comes up among enthusiasts. Known for their exceptional build quality and superb cooling performance, Noctua coolers have been a favorite in the PC building community for years. A typical Noctua cooler will be punctuated by incredibly quiet fans and top-notch cooling efficiency overall, which has made them ideal for overclockers and builders who want to keep their systems running cool and quiet.
In this review, we'll be taking a closer look at the NH-D15 G2 cooler, the successor to the legendary NH-D15. This cooler comes with a hefty price tag of $150 but promises to deliver the best performance that an air cooler can currently achieve. The NH-D15 G2 is available in three versions: one standard version as well as two specialized variants – LBC (Low Base Convexity) and HBC (High Base Convexity). These variants are designed to make better contact with specific CPUs; the LBC is recommended for AMD AM5 processors, while the HBC is tailored for Intel LGA1700 processors, mirroring the slightly different geometry of their respective heatspeaders. Conversely, the standard version is an “one size fits all” approach for users who care more about long-term compatibility over squeezing out every ounce of potential the cooler has.
For this review, we're looking at the LBC version, as our solid copper testing station has no convexity, ensuring optimal performance evaluation.
Noctua NH-D15 G2 CPU Cooler Specifications |
|||
Type | Air Cooler (Dual Tower) | ||
Dimensions | 168 x 150 x 127 mm (H x W x D) 1525 gr |
||
Fans | 2 x 140 mm SSO2 Bearing Fans 1525/1475 RPM (max) |
||
RGB | No | ||
Supported Sockets | Intel: LGA1851, LGA1700, LGA1200, LGA115x AMD: AM5 / AM4 |
||
Warranty | 6 Years | ||
Price | $150 |
Packaging & Bundle
We received the NH-D15 G2 in a remarkably sturdy cardboard box. Noctua continues their tradition of using elegant, information-focused artwork on the packaging of all their products, opting for simplicity over flashy design. Their entire packaging is made of recyclable cardboard, with the sole exception being the small plastic shield of the cooler’s base.
Inside the box, the cooler was securely nestled beneath multiple layers of thick cardboard, ensuring excellent protection. The mounting hardware and additional accessories were neatly organized in a smaller, compartmentalized box within the main package. We should note that there isn't any mounting hardware for Threadripper or LGA20XX processors in the packaging, probably because Noctua offers specialized solutions for these processors.
Alongside the usual mounting hardware required to install the NH-D15 G2 onto a CPU socket, Noctua includes several additional accessories. Inside the box, you'll find a Torx screwdriver, a fan power splitter cable, two "low noise" adapters to limit fan speed, a tube of NT-H2 thermal grease, a thermal paste wipe, and a metallic case badge.
The Noctua NH-D15 G2 CPU Cooler
Noctua designed the NH-D15 G2 as their pinnacle air cooler, aimed at achieving the highest possible performance while adhering to the company's minimalist and elegant design ethos, with no unnecessary decorations.
Physically, the NH-D15 G2 is a massive – though relatively simple – CPU cooler. Fully assembled, it weighs over 1.5 kg, and that's despite the heavy use of lightweight aluminum.
Design-wise, Noctua has stuck with a classic dual-tower design, with the array of fins floating above a small base and relying on heatpipes to transfer thermal energy away from that base to the main body of the cooler. This cooler features optimized asymmetrical fin stacks and an improved fan arrangement that allows for a reduced fin spacing from 1.9mm to 1.6mm. This adjustment enabled the integration of 23 extra fins, increasing the total fin surface area by 20% compared to the NH-D15. We should note that the thinner fins also are a bit flimsier and can be easily damaged if mishandled.
Compared to the original NH-D15, Noctua increased the number of heatpipes from six to eight. The heatpipes are made of copper but are nickel-plated for durability and aesthetics. The joints between the heatpipes and the fins are all soldered, ensuring maximum thermal transfer and mechanical cohesion.
Despite these insertions, the NH-D15 G2 is slightly smaller than its predecessor. The thick fin array and the presence of two fans make the cooler wide, but Noctua has ensured that it stays clear of the PCI Express slots on a typical (m)ATX motherboard. However, it may partially block some RAM slots, limiting RAM height on these slots to 32 mm when both fans are installed (standard RAM height).
Noctua’s engineers optimized airflow and acoustics by using two 140 mm fans instead of one. The fans used are the company’s own designs with SSO2 engines (a combination of fluid dynamic bearing with a magnetic levitation technique). Interestingly, the two fans are actually slightly different, as each has its own speed rating (1475 RPM & 1525 RPM). According to the company, by slightly offsetting the fan speeds by approximately 25 RPM, it minimizes undesirable harmonic effects like periodic humming or intermittent vibrations. This technique supposedly ensures smoother acoustic performance without compromising cooling efficiency. Users can further adjust the offset using PWM control or low-noise adapters for personalized acoustics.
The base of the cooler that makes contact with the processor is split into two parts. The bottom half is made of nickel-plated copper, maximizing the heat transfer rate from the CPU to the heatpipes. It is extremely well-machined and smooth. As we've previously noted, just how convex the base is will depend on the version of the cooler – our LBC version appears to be perfectly flat, while the regular and HBC versions would be increasingly convex. The top metal brace serves only as mechanical support.
22 Comments
View All Comments
Hresna - Sunday, August 18, 2024 - link
Water-cooling is an option for people that want to operate recent-gen intel at full-power stock defaults, but it’s not the only option. The chips remain very performant if you tune them down a bit, and the efficiency increases substantially. They will never be as efficient as their Ryzen contemporaries in PPW, but their feature set might still make them worthwhile for a lot of use cases.Granted, turning down a CPU for efficiency is a decidedly unpopular thing to do, even among enthusiasts. But I think we might see it become a bit more common for them to release with more conservative performance profiles. AMD even seems to have left a good amount of headroom on their 9000 series, perhaps looking to avoid some of intels’ recent pitfalls.
Some data on 13th gen power scaling:
https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/10bna5r...
Silver5urfer - Tuesday, August 13, 2024 - link
Wasn't there a factory defect on these ? Noctua did not announce any recall but it was under investigation.https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cooling...
That said the Cooler this round is overpriced. I have the Chromax Black DH15 on an LGA1200 socket. There's very minimal advantage going the G2 route. Also no Chromax edition, no G2 Chromax fans either, the heatsink cover is also not there yet. Skip it.
As for convex/concave designs, Intel LGA1700 is a disaster that must be avoided at all costs due to CPU bending, Socket PCB bending, latest RPL silicon degradation due to poor silicon engineering. There's no reason why anyone should even consider buying this cooler for that platform, not only it will be inadequate for a 13th 14th gen i9 processors but also worthless. The heat density is also higher on 13th and 14th like of 11th gen, too hot for an Aircooler.
Khanan - Tuesday, August 13, 2024 - link
It was a small problem with the first batch and was fixed quickly by Noctua / not even all were affected (afaik).rpg1966 - Tuesday, August 13, 2024 - link
The final chart that Anandtech includes is great. But I don't understand why none of the tech sites I read don't plot noise vs temp-over-ambient, maybe additionally colouring or sizing each plotted point to indicate the price.Ryan Smith - Tuesday, August 13, 2024 - link
The issue comes down to temp-over-ambient at what power level. It's a 3 dimensional function, which makes for a very ugly plot.That's why E opted for noise vs thermal resistance. TR is (mostly) constant, so it allows you to plot noise versus just a single variable on a 2D graph.
rpg1966 - Wednesday, August 14, 2024 - link
Understood. It might take a couple of charts, e.g. one at 100W, one at 200W (or whatever)? Anyway, good job with the last chart, great info.casteve - Tuesday, August 13, 2024 - link
Thanks for the review. I love the thermal resistance vs sound pressure graph...but..this is clearly an air cooler designed for much higher loads than 100W. At 100W, I'd throw the U12A and U12S on there as the competition - The U12S is half the price, and at 100W cools just fine and is significantly quieter. I'm guessing the 550rpm @ low speed is at or below your noise floor.Add the 200W results, please.
NorthRocks - Monday, August 19, 2024 - link
Currently using 2-3 original D15 models.The fact that the older models actually performs better at lower RPM makes upgrading seem bit pointless to me. The CPUs I use (Ryzen 9 7900X etc.) seldom run at maximum power.dqniel - Monday, August 19, 2024 - link
Absolutely insane price. The performance and support is good, but so is the performance and support of other companies... without the insane price.Oxford Guy - Thursday, August 22, 2024 - link
Considering how long these last and inflation, $150 is hardly insane.