Display Report: Huawei P10 and P10 Plusby Matt Humrick on April 14, 2017 3:00 PM EST
- Posted in
- P10 Plus
Huawei recently added the P10 and P10 Plus to its lineup, which focus on fashion and photography like other P-series phones. The Huawei P10 has a 5.1-inch IPS LCD panel with a typical 1920x1080 resolution (431ppi) and a 16:9 aspect ratio. The P10 Plus, as its name implies, is an upscaled version of the P10, with a larger 5.5-inch IPS LCD panel. It also bumps resolution to 2560x1440 (534ppi), which is not really necessary for an IPS panel at this size. Both panels are covered with Gorilla Glass 5 and come with a plastic screen protector pre-applied. Some people may appreciate the extra protection included out of the box, but the cheap protector does not allow your finger to slide smoothly across the screen and gets gunked up with skin oil very quickly. The glass underneath does not appear to have an oleophobic coating either, which is an odd omission for a flagship phone.
A well-calibrated, quality display would be a nice compliment to the dual rear cameras on both phones, allowing you to view the captured photos accurately. Previous Huawei phones have suffered from poor calibration, however, so we’ll take some measurements to see if there’s any improvement with the new P10s. As always, we use an X-Rite i1Pro 2 spectrophotometer for color measurements and an i1Display Pro colorimeter for luminance measurements, profiling it with SpectraCal's CalMAN software.
Both the P10 and P10 Plus exceed 500 nits at peak brightness, a little shy of the 600+ nits a few phones can achieve, including Huawei’s Mate 9, and a little less than last year’s P9. It’s not clear if the P10’s backlight is using 20 LEDs like the P9 or if it has gone back to using 16 LEDs, which is more common for a 5-inch class display.
The values in the chart above were measured by setting the brightness manually. Many phones, especially those with OLED displays, can temporarily boost brightness to increase visibility in extreme cases such as direct sunlight when using the auto-brightness mode. The iPhone 7 and 7 Plus, for example, hit 706 and 618 nits, respectively, and Samsung’s Galaxy S7 hits 532 nits using this boost mode. The P10s do not have this auto-brightness boost feature; however, their peak brightness is still sufficient for outdoor use. At the other extreme, brightness drops all the way down to 2-3 nits at the minimum setting, making the P10s easy to use in a completely dark room.
Black level and contrast ratio are measured at the panel’s maximum brightness. Because black level increases with brightness, the numbers in the chart above are not directly comparable; however, after accounting for this effect, black levels for the iPhone 6s Plus, iPhone 7 Plus, Mi MIX, and both P10s are comparable, so the P10 displays are likely using photo-aligned crystals to improve black level and contrast ratio.
The phones with OLED panels are not shown in these charts because they are able to achieve a black level of zero and a mathematically infinite contrast ratio by being able to completely turn off individual pixels.
Huawei is notorious for calibrating its displays to an overly cool white point, and the P10s are no exception. With an average white point of about 8,400K when using the “Default” setting, a little higher than both the P9 and Mate 9, the P10s show an obvious blue tint when looking at a white screen. The imbalance between the blue and red primaries leads to poor grayscale accuracy. Average ΔE2000 grayscale error is greater than 6 with peak error reaching 8-10 at higher luminance values.
Like other Huawei phones, the P10s allow you to adjust the white point by selecting predefined “Cold” or “Warm” color temperature modes. You can also set a custom white point target by dragging a finger around a color wheel. The Cold setting shifts the average white point to about 9,000K, giving the screen an even darker blue tint. The Warm setting still shows a deficit in red, giving it an average white point of 7,400K, still well above the D65 target value, shifting the screen’s tint from blue to aqua.
The "Custom" white point setting for both the P10 and P10 Plus
Using the P10’s color wheel, I was able to adjust the RGB balance, giving a small boost to the red primary while pulling green closer to the ideal value. In the “Custom” graphs above, you can see how this reduces grayscale error over the full luminance range. Despite these improvements, I was not able to get average CCT below about 7,600K, so the screen still has a blue tint.
The P10s use adaptive display technology that adjusts both the backlight intensity and gamma based on the content being displayed and the ambient light conditions. This technology aims to reduce power consumption and improve the display’s visibility, especially when using the phone outdoors.
Both P10s use wide color gamut displays that nearly cover the entire DCI-P3 color space, only falling short of the blue target value. This leads to oversaturated colors when viewing content that targets the sRGB color space (shown by the inner triangle in the graphs above) because of Android’s lack of color management. The Default and Cold settings exhibit the greatest saturation error, especially for color shades beyond the 50% saturation level. There’s also a significant shift in hue towards blue because of the cool white point. The Warm and custom settings achieve a better RGB balance, significantly reducing both hue shift and saturation error to more acceptable levels, at least out to about the 60% mark. The P10s do not have an sRGB mode, so people that prefer accurate rather than vibrant colors are out of luck.
Measuring the spectral power distribution (SPD) of the P10 Plus’ backlight with a spectrometer shows how it and the smaller P10 cover a wider color gamut. Typical sRGB panels use blue LEDs, resulting in a sharp peak around 450nm. These are coated with a yellow photoreactive phosphor that creates smaller, broader peaks in the green and orange portions of the spectrum. The backlights used in the P10s still use blue LEDs, which is evident from the same sharp peak at 450nm, but the sharper peak output in the green and red portions of the spectrum are the result of using red and green phosphors instead of a single yellow phosphor.
Using the P10’s Default setting provides similar color accuracy to the Mate 9 and is a little better than the P9, both at their Default settings. For the colors tested, ΔE2000 error hovers around the critical threshold of 3, above which color error is easily noticeable. Most of the error results from the wide gamut panel and oversaturated colors, but the cool white point also produces significant hue shift. The Warm and customized settings produce better results by reducing the error from hue shift.
Our P10 and P10 Plus did not show any backlight bleed or issues with luminance uniformity. Viewing angles are also very good, avoiding the noticeable white, red-tinted glow that affects the Mate 9 even at shallow viewing angles. The P10s have some IPS glow, but it’s very minor when viewing the screen normally in portrait or landscape mode, only becoming noticeable when looking across the screen diagonally, which is not something you would normally do. There are not any significant issues when viewing the displays through polarized sunglasses either, with only a very slight reduction in brightness in landscape mode.
Display performance for the P10 and P10 Plus is similar to other recent Huawei phones. The wide gamut panels are bright enough to view outside and produce vibrant, but not particularly accurate, colors. They also share the same overly cool white point, which gives the screens a noticeable blue tint. Using the Warm setting, or adjusting the white point manually, improves both grayscale and color accuracy, but accuracy remains elusive even when using the manual option because of poor calibration. The viewing angle improvements are certainly a step in the right direction, but the P10s cannot match the display quality of other flagship phones.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
Ian Cutress - Friday, April 14, 2017 - linkOne of my thoughts recently is that EMUI 5.0 is a very blue interface, and Huawei continually stated that the blue and white GUI was to symbolise nature and water etc. The easiest way to make an interface look more blue is to calibrate the screens to that effect. Perhaps screens with a blue tint are cheaper to buy than a fully accurate one. But it's consistently on nearly every successive Huawei device since the Mate S/P9 at least (even before EMUI 5.0. Asking Huawei yielded no results, because in the end we don't talk to anyone who would make that kind of decision (if it were intentional).
I'm running my Mate 9 with eye comfort mode continually on, just so it isn't as cool and piercing. Same with the Mate 8.
Aerodrifting - Friday, April 14, 2017 - linkWhy are they so stubborn, They could have set the color temp right from the beginning instead of having everyone bashing the blue tint.
zepi - Friday, April 14, 2017 - linkWhy don't you start measuring contrast between RGB(1,1,1) instead of RGB(0,0,0) and to RGB(255,255,255)? Solves the oled issue and actually gives more meaningful results for "lowest decipherable signal".
Digital audio dynamics is not considered to be infinite, despite 0 is a valid value for audio signal. Why should we measure display output differently?
You could provide dynamic range in addition of the normal contrast ratio.
ddriver - Saturday, April 15, 2017 - linkThere is really no oled issue, even if the oled itself doesn't emit light when black, it is not a perfect black body by any means. It will still reflect some ambient light, therefore the contrast ratio will not be infinity, just some very high number relative to tfts.
This could be an issue for charts if linear scale is used, logarithmic would do the job, but perceiving the results adequately might end up being a challenge for your-typical-AT-enthusiast.
serendip - Friday, April 14, 2017 - linkWhat's with the blue tint on most Chinese phones? Do Chinese consumers prefer a blue-white tint?
Even Xiaomi stuff has this issue. When I was running MIUI on a Mi Max, I set the color temp to Warm. Now on LineageOS, I manually set the RGB display values to get a much warmer color temp.
ddriver - Saturday, April 15, 2017 - linkThey do it to maximize brightness to battery life ratio. Chinese consumers prefer bright displays and better battery life. Most people, Chinese and others, don't care about accuracy, be that image, audio or whatever. For audio there is also the paradox that many people would actually prefer cheap, high distortion reproduction with scooped mids and boosted lows to the clean and accurate sound of a reference speaker.
centurio9 - Saturday, April 15, 2017 - linkI will never understand the need for wide viewing angles on a smartphone. Its my private sphere and I don't want the guy sitting next to me or standing in front of me to be able to see what I'm doing on my phone...A tablet is one thing, but not my smartphone. That's why I'll never buy a phone with a super amoled screen.
ddriver - Sunday, April 16, 2017 - linkGood viewing angles on phones are not a design target, they are accidental benefits of using panels that are not TN garbage.
omejames - Monday, October 30, 2017 - linkHi!guys play here bejeweled free online and enjoy full on entertainment click here and follow the link to play it http://bejeweled3.co this one is title matching puzzle video games.Thanks for this one.